Checking Whether your COIDA Assessment is Correct

18 Nov 2026

By Jodi Poswelletski | Director and Amanda Kubheka | Candidate Attorney 

Paying a COIDA assessment can become a routine annual expense. A business submits its Return of Earnings, receives an assessment and pays the amount due. Yet an incorrect business classification or earnings figure can leave an employer paying more than it should, even where its submissions and payments are up to date.

The Compensation for Occupational Injuries and Diseases Act 130 of 1993 (COIDA) provides compensation for work-related injuries and diseases. Employers’ assessments help fund that system. For a business concerned about its assessment, the starting point is to understand how the amount was calculated and whether the information behind it is correct.

 

Recognising a possible overpayment

COIDA assessments are generally calculated by applying the relevant assessment tariff to employees’ assessable annual earnings. The business classification determines the applicable tariff, while COIDA’s earnings rules determine the amount to which it is applied. An error in either can affect what the employer pays.

Start with the business classification recorded by the Compensation Fund. Does it accurately describe the work the business carries out? A category allocated when the business first registered may warrant another look if its activities have changed, or if the original description was inaccurate. A classification associated with higher-risk operations deserves attention where those operations do not reflect the business’s activities.

Next, compare the earnings used in the assessment with the Return of Earnings and supporting payroll records. Check whether the assessment is provisional, based on estimated earnings, or reflects actual earnings for the relevant period. COIDA also prescribes how earnings are calculated and sets an annual earnings ceiling per employee for the relevant assessment year, so the figure used is not necessarily the business’s full payroll total.

An unexplained increase is another reason to investigate. A higher assessment may follow a legitimate change in earnings or tariffs, but it should be possible to account for the difference. Where the amount demanded includes arrears, penalties or interest, separate these from the assessment itself and check that previous payments have been credited.

In a recent matter considered by Fairbridges, an employer had been classified under a substantially higher-risk category that did not correspond with the nature of its business. The review identified a potentially more appropriate category carrying a substantially lower tariff. The example illustrates how a classification issue can have a significant financial effect.

These checks can reveal a discrepancy worth investigating. Establishing whether an overpayment has occurred, and what can be done about it, requires a closer examination of the assessment and the rules that apply.

 

Putting an incorrect assessment right

A review must establish which classification and tariff properly apply to the business’s activities for the period concerned. This requires the relevant tariff documents and classification rules, together with evidence of what the business actually does. Where its activities span more than one category, that analysis can be particularly important.

The earnings calculation needs similar scrutiny. Payroll records, Returns of Earnings, assessment notices, account statements and payment confirmations should be reconciled to establish where any discrepancy arose. If the problem extends across several years, each period needs to be considered separately, including the applicable earnings ceiling and any additional charges.

The appropriate remedy depends on the source of the problem. It may involve an application to change the business classification, correcting declared earnings and seeking a revised assessment, or lodging a formal objection under section 91 of COIDA. These processes have different requirements and deadlines, making it important to identify the correct route promptly.

Correcting the position going forward does not automatically establish an entitlement to a refund for earlier years. Whether historical assessments can be revisited, and whether related penalties or interest can be challenged, depends on the facts, supporting records and applicable procedure.

Fairbridges can help employers review their classification and assessments, identify the basis for a correction and prepare the necessary submissions to the Compensation Fund. We can also advise on associated arrears and Letter of Good Standing issues, particularly where these affect tenders, contracts or access to client sites. An assessment that cannot be reconciled with your business’s activities and records is a practical starting point for that review.

Discuss Article with the Author

Recent Articles

Dhahini Naidu Appointed to TerraLex’s NextGen Advisory Committee

Dhahini Naidu Appointed to TerraLex’s NextGen Advisory Committee

The value of a Restraint of Trade in a business acquisition

The value of a Restraint of Trade in a business acquisition

Raising a Rule 6(5)(d)(iii) Notice Before the Rule 53 Record: An Irregular Step or a Competent Election?

Raising a Rule 6(5)(d)(iii) Notice Before the Rule 53 Record: An Irregular Step or a Competent Election?

When does a commercial dispute become an insolvency problem?

When does a commercial dispute become an insolvency problem?